Humphreys Half Moon Inn & Suit

Very efficient check in, friendly staff, beautiful rooms, and very comfortable room.

Humphrey's is simply wonderful. The pool area and the fire pits -- it's like you're in another world. The rooms are large and comfortable. The view of the marina is cool. The cost is competitive with the mid-chains but the experience is so much better. Shelter Island is an awesome location. I'd give it more than 5 stars if I could.

This was our second time staying at Humphrey's for a girls' trip, and it was even better the second time. The location is great, and it's like being on a tropical vacation while never leaving California. The staff greeting us was kind and professional. All the hotel staff was friendly and courteous. Big shout out to Sierra at the Oasis Pool Bar for being a great, friendly asset to this hotel. Bonus points to also being able to listen to concerts from our deck even if we didn't have tickets to the show.