Gudamendi
3.0 / 5
Paseo De Gudamendi, S/N Monte Igeldo, San Sebastian






Reviews from Guests
View all
3.0/5
285
Reviews
from real guests
Curiosity659528
2
/
5
We spent 10 days in this 4-star hotel, but actually 3. Nice people at the reception, we found the service in the bar/restaurant a bit less. Outright unfriendly.
The hotel is dated, old, the cabinet doors were defective, the beds were okay but very small.
The pool was ice cold and very uninviting, just concrete around and not really inviting to stay there.
We had asked in advance if our dog was welcome at the hotel, we were told yes, extra costs were also charged, by the way, normal for any hotel. But our dog was never allowed to stay alone in the hotel room. What a big problem it could become, especially if you consider that dogs are not welcome anywhere in San Sebastian, restaurants, beaches, etc.
In good consultation with the very friendly employee Helmut, this was achieved, also because they saw that our dog was a calm dog and never barks.
In the large backyard there was a nice field where our dog could play a little with a ball for a maximum of 10 minutes at a time, we were able to do that 4 to 5 days out of our 10 days, 2 times 10 per day because it was too hot. On the terrace, hotel, and so on, a dog was not allowed to run loose, completely agree, but nothing was said about the backyard where no one was.
To our great surprise, we once saw a large dog not walking on a leash in the garden, a very aggressive dog, peeing and pooping everywhere in the garden. I made a report at the reception, and what do you know? This dog belonged to the hotel owner who maintained an authoritarian rule within the hotel towards guests and hotel staff.
Note: this lady lives next to the hotel and her living room has a view of the hotel's large garden.
Oddly enough, and the day after we reported the loose and defecating dog in the garden, we were forbidden to let our dog play with his ball for 10 minutes in the garden where no one had ever been.
And a very childish, unfriendly, and short-sighted reaction from the owner of this hotel.
She sets rules for paying guests but sets the worst example imaginable; she didn't clean up the dog's excrement herself but had her staff do it. I wonder what century this lady escaped from.
After this remarkable behavior of the owner, we decided not to come back to this hotel.
Rooms: 1/5 | Service: 1/5 | Location: 2/5
Rooms
The double bed was very small, actually a kind of twin bed of 1.30m or so. Rooms for two were a bit cramped and small. Definitely for a 4-star hotel.
Walkability
Only by car
Hotel highlights
Great view
Breakfast type
Limited selection
Bed comfort
Neutral
Room view
Ocean view
callmeDreamerIsabell
4
/
5
Very beautiful hotel, with a nice outdoor space where you can eat, a beautiful and clean room, good breakfast,
but with very little choice. Staff not particularly kind; they made a mistake during the booking and never even apologized. If I had found an alternative, I would have canceled the booking.
mar_ajosed403
2
/
5
The best things were the views and cleanliness, but everything else was terrible and disappointing, not deserving of 4 stars. 5 km by road from the center of San Sebastián, so a car is mandatory, but that is not the worst part; the worst part is the dining, very basic, bad, and with an extremely rude staff, bad answers, and no kindness whatsoever; it seems like they are doing you a favor by serving you, with a tremendous amount of absurd rules and no sensitivity whatsoever regarding people's situations. One night they refused to make a reservation for us, when in previous days they told us that we had to reserve first thing in the morning, and it was nine in the morning; when we went to the front desk they told us that they had nothing to do with the restaurant but that they would let the owners know. The solution was for us to bring our own food from outside and eat at some tables in the lobby. A solution that we found unacceptable; I do not understand the four-star rating, which is clearly given away.
Of the four rooms we had, one smelled of dampness and clearly requires remodeling of the facilities and furniture. I do not recommend it if you are expecting a 4-star hotel, and I will not be returning.
Facilities Details
View all
Free Wifi
Facilities Details
Internet Access in public areas
Free Wifi