Carriage Way Bed & Breakfast

My wife and I stayed at the Carriage Way Inn in the Aquamarine room in July 2026. Lisa greeted us when we arrived around noon (Check-in is 2 p to 5 p) and our room was not yet ready but we were able to park our car and Lisa promised to contact us once it was ready. We went out to explore St. Augustine old town area and had some ice cream. Lisa called a little while later, as promised, saying our room was ready and we returned. Lisa gave us a mini tour of the main house, built in 1883, and of our room. The Aquamarine room is on the second floor (no elevator). The room was clean, with sufficient storage for a week-long stay for two, and the king bed was comfortable – we slept well. There are outlets on each side of the bed as well as one under an occasional table under the TV, so no shortage of outlets to charge electronic devices. One outlet is about 3+ feet away from the end table but I had 4’ charge cables that worked well. There is one mini-split AC/heater unit in the room that is whisper-quiet, remote-controlled, and could maintain the room at 68 degrees in the heat of the day if you wanted to. The bathroom is tight but has all the amenities needed as well as a large walk-in shower with good pressure and plenty of hot water. It is a one person at a time bathroom unless one is taking a shower and the other is at the sink. The main house is located on a quiet street and we were never bothered by noise when we were sleeping. There are occasional vehicles with loud music and party carts with loud people but that seemed to quiet down by 10pm and we heard it only on Friday and Saturday nights. Breakfast is served from 8am to 10am. Just come in and, grab a cup of coffee, maybe some OJ, and someone will stop, describe that morning‘s breakfast and then bring it out in a few minutes. Most days we were there, it was a quiche of some sort, cooked in-house. I am not a big quiche fan but my wife likes them. However, every quiche they served was delicious! Breakfast also included a scone, or fruit or pancakes. Portions were just right for us. I was never stuffed, but also never felt like I wanted more. They always asked if it was enough and I am sure they would provide another serving with a smile if you ask. The Carriage Way Inn is located on the edge of the old town area and you can comfortably walk anywhere in the area in a 10 or 15 or 15 minute stroll or 5 to 8 minutes in a hurry. Parking is limited so let them know in advance. I don’t know that they would permit a full size pickup or even a suburban sized SUV. We had a Toyota Rav4. Public parking lots in the old town area that I saw all had $20.00 or $25.00 signs to park.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Our stay at the Carriage Way Bed & Breakfast Inn was absolutely wonderful and exceeded our expectations. From the moment we arrived, we felt welcomed and cared for. The inn is intimate, charming, and filled with thoughtful little touches that make your stay feel comfortable, relaxing, and special. A heartfelt thank you to Lisa, the manager, who was truly exceptional. She was warm, accommodating, attentive, and always willing to help. Her genuine hospitality and dedication to her guests made a lasting impression on us and added so much to our overall experience. One of the things we loved most about this inn is that it feels like stepping into history. The property is rich with character and stories from the past, offering an experience that simply cannot be replicated in a modern hotel. Because it is a historic home, it’s important for guests to understand that preserving its authenticity comes with certain limitations. If something appears older or needs attention, remember that many repairs and updates require city approval to maintain the historical integrity of the property. Lisa does an incredible job balancing preservation with guest comfort, and that deserves appreciation. Another highlight that should not be missed is the breakfast. The home-style breakfast was absolutely delicious—fresh, comforting, and clearly prepared with care. It was one of our favorite parts of the stay and the perfect way to start each morning. Make sure you don’t sleep in and miss it! We encourage future guests to embrace the charm, history, and unique character of this beautiful inn. Focus on the many wonderful things it has to offer: the welcoming atmosphere, outstanding hospitality, delicious breakfast, convenient location, and the feeling of being transported back to another era. If you’re looking for a memorable, authentic St. Augustine experience with genuine hospitality, Carriage Way Bed & Breakfast Inn is a true gem. We would gladly stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone who appreciates history, charm, and personal touches that make a place feel like home.

I rarely leave reviews, but I felt this experience warranted honest feedback. My husband and I booked the Amethyst Room for our anniversary based on the photos and descriptions provided online. Unfortunately, the property did not fully meet the expectations those images created. As Florida residents, we understand the recent cold weather likely impacted landscaping and outdoor upkeep. However, the courtyard and exterior areas appeared noticeably more worn and less maintained than what is currently advertised online. Updating the photos or refreshing the outdoor spaces would help future guests have a more accurate understanding of the property’s current condition. There were certainly positive aspects to our stay. The location was excellent, the included parking was convenient, and every staff member we encountered was kind and welcoming. That said, at approximately $375 per night, we anticipated a higher level of overall quality in the accommodations, amenities, and breakfast experience. While the room itself was comfortable enough, it lacked the charm, attention to detail, and elevated feel we expected at this price point. Breakfast was also disappointing; we only chose to participate one of the two mornings because the selection felt quite basic. In a destination like St. Augustine, we expected a more memorable and refined hospitality experience. The toiletries also felt below the standard we anticipated for a property in this category. The shampoo and body wash were small sample sized bottles that did not feel particularly premium or thoughtfully curated. Additionally, we experienced an issue with the tub jets during our first night. The jets repeatedly turned on by themselves, and we had to troubleshoot the wall switches multiple times to stop them, which became frustrating and disruptive. Overall, it felt as though the premium pricing was driven primarily by the location rather than the full guest experience. We have stayed at similarly priced bed and breakfast properties in Savannah and found the room quality, amenities, and dining experience there to be significantly more impressive. I genuinely wanted to love this property and had hoped it might become an annual anniversary destination for us, which makes this disappointment even more unfortunate. I share this feedback constructively because I do believe the property has strong potential with a few thoughtful improvements.