There seems to be a new practice in tourist hotels to hold ridiculous amounts for incidentals. At this hotel it is 50$ which I understand goes towards their cash flow needs (since the money is taken out of my account) and was justified by incidentals such as bags of chips and phone charges (phone charges ? in 2024 ?). I am not happy about that, nor about the fact that the gym is super-small and with one treadmill only, that was out of service.
Still the hotel gets 3 star because the location is excellent just across the road from the Faunces Tavern, the bed was comfortable and the shower in good order, and the breakfast was yummy and free.